Home > Resources > Performance Excellence & Benchmarking > Reports, Research and White Papers

Reports, Research and White Papers

The following reports are produced annually by the Performance Excellence & Benchmarking programs:
 

Forced Outage Performance of Transmission Equipment
The report contains information on the performance of transmission equipment in Canada. Information from the report can be used by utility companies for benchmarking transmission line performance, to make decisions regarding new transmission line construction and existing line upgrades and to focus resources for maintenance programs and system planning in order to maximize performance.
 
In 2007, information was provided by participating utilities on
  • over 200,000 kilometers of transmission lines
  • over 20,000 circuit breakers
  • over 5000 transformer banks
  • over 900 kilometers in cables
  • over 40 synchronous compensators
  • over 20 static compensators
  • over 1500 shunt reactor banks
  • over 1200 shunt capacitor banks each
  • over 100 series capacitor banks
 
Some general transmission line trends show in the 2007 report include:
  • The mean duration for outages of transmission lines has been relatively stable over the five year period (2003-2007), showing a slight decrease of 15% in the final year.
  • The number of outages on transmission lines also remained relatively stable over the five year period; however, the number of outages decreased significantly from 2006 to 2007, by 35%.
 
The 2007 report shows some interesting trends in outages:
  • Forced outage time due to transformer banks decreased by approximately 7% over the five year period ending in 2007. The number of forced outages also decreased by almost 8% over the same period.
  • The number of forced outages for circuit breakers has increased consistently over five years. The increase for the five year period was approximately 11%.
  • The number of forced outages for series capacitors decreased by 58%, however, the average time to repair increased significantly, by 83%.
  • The number of outages due to cable performance decreased by 59%, however, the mean duration showed an increase of 189% over the five year period.
  • The number of outages from 2003 to 2007 remained relatively stable while the mean duration of the outages decreased by 57% from 2003.
  • The mean duration for outages and the number of outages for static compensator performance both remained relatively stable.
  • The number of outages for shunt reactor banks remained relatively stable over the years, while the mean duration time of the outages decreased by 33% from 2003.
  • The number of outages for shunt capacitor banks decreased by 13%, while the mean duration time of the outages increased by 55.8%.
 

Generation Equipment Status
The report contains information on the performance of electrical generating units in Canada. Information from the report can be used by utility companies for benchmarking Generating Unit performance, to make decisions regarding new Generating Unit Construction and existing Unit upgrades and to focus resources for maintenance programs and system planning in order to maximize performance.
 
For the 2007 report, information was provided by participating utilities on
  • 456 Hydraulic Units resulting in total forced outage time of 8.4 years
  • 80 Fossil Units(Coal, Oil, Natural Gas) resulting in total forced outage time of 3.3 years
  • 29 Combustion Turbine Units resulting in total forced outage time of 109 days
  • 11 Nuclear Units resulting in total forced outage time of 1.7 years

Key causes of forced outages and deratings for Generating Units in 2007 include:
  • Hydraulic Units – (1)Telecom and Communications, (2) Excitation
  • Fossil Units – (1) Waterwalls, (2) Superheater
  • Combustion Turbine Units – (1) Combustion Turbine, (2) Controls and Instrumentation
  • Nuclear – (1) Reactor Reactivity Control Units, (2) Main Heat Transport Circuit

5 Year data trends indicate the following:
  • Hydraulic –Increase of 78% over 5 years in average forced outage duration
  • Fossil – 25% steady decrease in forced outages due to components in Steam Generation Facilities over 5 years
  • Combustion Turbine – Experiencing a decrease in use although available over 5 year period
  • Nuclear – Significant increase of 139% over 5 years in average forced outage duration
 

Annual Service Continuity Report on Distribution System Performance in Electrical Utilities
The report presents some industry standard metrics for the electricity distribution including:
  • System Average Interruption Frequency Index (SAIFI)
  • System Average Interruption Duration Index (SAIDI)
  • Customer Average Interruption Duration Index (CAIDI)
  • Index of Reliability (IOR)
 
By using the above metrics in combination with the cause of an electricity interruption, utility companies can
  • set targets for improvement
  • develop programs in support of their improvement targets
  • make design/build decisions that try to mitigate interruption causes